Who's Most Likely To: 100+ Juicy Questions

April 24, 2025 Friends playing the Who's Most Likely To game

Alright, we've had some laughs with the classic questions, but sometimes, you wanna dig a little bit deeper, right? Ask those questions that are a bit more probing, that might make you blush, that reveal those hidden quirks or slightly more... personal stories. That's where Juicy "Who's Most Likely To...?" questions come in!

Hold up, the goal here isn't to make anyone feel awkward or start drama. The idea is to play this with friends you trust, in a supportive atmosphere with good vibes only. This is for those late-night chats, when everyone's ready to open up a bit more, to share those "unmentionable" but ultimately harmless things that make us human (and often pretty funny).

These juicy questions are perfect for discovering new sides of your friends (and yourself!). So, ready to play along?

Spill the Tea (Gently!): 100+ Juicy Who's Most Likely To Questions

Bring out the light dirt, the little embarrassments, and the weird habits. Let's get into it!

Who's most likely to stalk their ex (or a friend's crush) on Insta all the way back to their 2015 pics?
Who's most likely to lie about their age (even by just a year or two) for some weird reason?
Who's most likely to cry watching a heartwarming TikTok video (like an animal rescue)? C'mon, admit it.
Who's most likely to have cheated on an exam or test... and gotten away with it? (Statute of limitations, hopefully!)
Who's most likely to spend a slightly crazy amount of money on something totally useless they saw online?
Who's most likely to still be a little scared of the dark and leave a nightlight on (or the hallway light)?
Who's most likely to read their horoscope every morning and ACTUALLY believe it?
Who's most likely to have an embarrassing guilty pleasure song (like, secretly blasting Céline Dion)?
Who's most likely to have taken a (very quick!) peek at someone else's phone without permission?
Who's most likely to have a completely useless talent they've totally mastered (like cracking all their knuckles)?
Who's most likely to have pretended to be someone else online (just for laughs, of course)?
Who's most likely to have the most minor OCD tendencies (checking the door 10 times, lining things up...)?
Who's most likely to have gotten a small ticket for a silly reason (like jaywalking)?
Who's most likely to silently judge someone just by looking at their Spotify playlist?
Who's most likely to have a slightly embarrassing secret collection (figurines, rocks...)?
Who's most likely to have a really hard time saying "no," even when they really don't want to do something?
Who's most likely to have faked being sick (the classic "stomach ache") to get out of something?
Who's most likely to talk to their plants and give them little names?
Who's most likely to have the weirdest nicknames given by their family?
Who's most likely to have had a super AWKWARD minor car or bike accident?
Who's most likely to be the most superstitious (never walking under ladders, knocking on wood...)?
Who's most likely to have (slightly) exaggerated on their resume/CV?
Who's most likely to have the same weird and super specific dream often?
Who's most likely to be totally addicted to coffee, tea, or an energy drink? Like, need it to function.
Who's most likely to have broken up with someone via text? (We're judging... a little).
Who's most likely to have the worst sense of direction and get lost even with Google Maps?
Who's most likely to have made a VERY expensive impulse purchase and regretted it instantly?
Who's most likely to have a really strange and specific phobia (like holes, repetitive patterns, bare feet...)?
Who's most likely to secretly dream of being on a reality TV show (even the trashiest one)?
Who's most likely to still have a holey "lucky" pajama shirt or tee from when they were 12?
Who's most likely to have tried pet food (just out of curiosity)?
Who's most likely to have a "finsta" (fake Instagram) account or a secret social media profile?
Who's most likely to have cried at work or school (secretly)?
Who's most likely to have a secret crush on a fictional character?
Who's most likely to sing in the shower so loud the neighbors can hear?
Who's most likely to have "borrowed" clothes from a friend without asking and never returned them? Oops.
Who's most likely to spend hours watching "satisfying" videos (ASMR, soap cutting...)?
Who's most likely to have had a date end CATASTROPHICALLY?
Who's most likely to have a laughing fit in the middle of a serious situation (funeral, meeting...)?
Who's most likely to have a slightly gross eating habit (eating raw cookie dough, licking the plate...)?
Who's most likely to have lied to avoid lending something to someone?
Who's most likely to be able to have an entire conversation using only memes or GIFs?
Who's most likely to still have a poster of a teenage crush hanging in their childhood bedroom (at their parents' place)?
Who's most likely to have tried to cut their own hair... with questionable results?
Who's most likely to have an irrational fear of birds (or another common animal)?
Who's most likely to have forgotten one of their best friend's birthdays?
Who's most likely to spend more time choosing a profile pic than studying for an exam?
Who's most likely to have had a complete blackout (memory loss) after a night out?
Who's most likely to have a secret (and probably terrible) flirting technique?
Who's most likely to know all the lyrics to a cartoon theme song from their childhood by heart?
Who's most likely to have pretended they've read a book they never actually opened?
Who's most likely to have a dating app installed "just to look"?
Who's most likely to keep a diary or journal (even an electronic one)?
Who's most likely to have gone through a "goth," "emo," or some other questionable style phase as a teen? (Got pics?)
Who's most likely to blush bright red if someone gives them a compliment?
Who's most likely to have faked a phone call to escape an awkward conversation?
Who's most likely to have slightly extreme cleaning habits?
Who's most likely to have sent a text meant for their crush... to someone else (like the family group chat)? Nightmare.
Who's most likely to have a hidden talent for doing silly voices or impressions?
Who's most likely to be into conspiracy theories (even the really wild ones)?
Who's most likely to have laughed out loud during a sad movie scene?
Who's most likely to have a beauty/skincare routine that takes over an hour?
Who's most likely to have used a fake medical excuse to get something?
Who's most likely to have a "list" (mental or written) of people they've hooked up with?
Who's most likely to secretly watch makeover or home decorating shows?
Who's most likely to have gotten a ridiculous bruise or injury and made up a heroic story to explain it?
Who's most likely to have such a distinctive laugh you can recognize it from miles away?
Who's most likely to have made an impulse purchase during a 3 AM bout of insomnia?
Who's most likely to have a habit of constantly checking their notifications?
Who's most likely to have spied on a neighbor (just out of curiosity, obviously)?
Who's most likely to have a "secret" recipe that's actually terrible but they keep making it anyway?
Who's most likely to have cried tears of joy over something kind of trivial?
Who's most likely to have a super embarrassing username or email address from middle school?
Who's most likely to have made a massive blunder at a family dinner?
Who's most likely to have a special "sad vibes" playlist?
Who's most likely to have "lost" something to avoid lending it out?
Who's most likely to talk to themselves out loud (often)?
Who's most likely to have a foolproof technique for avoiding doing the dishes?
Who's most likely to have had a very serious conversation with their pet?
Who's most likely to have an alarm clock sound that's unbearable to everyone except them?
Who's most likely to have taken a selfie in a totally inappropriate situation?
Who's most likely to have a habit of always smelling their food before eating it?
Who's most likely to have had a totally embarrassing moment of "fame" online (an old video, a comment...)?
Who's most likely to believe in ghosts or spirits?
Who's most likely to have a habit of collecting free pens or other small freebies?
Who's most likely to have had an intense physical reaction (laughing, crying, yelling) while playing a video game?
Who's most likely to have an unofficial "uniform" (always wearing the same type of clothes)?
Who's most likely to have tried to communicate with spirits (Ouija board or something similar)?
Who's most likely to have a weird way of eating certain foods?
Who's most likely to have lied during a game just like this one? 😉
Who's most likely to have a paper planner filled with doodles and secret codes?
Who's most likely to have had a library fine for overdue books?
Who's most likely to have a habit of organizing everything by color?
Who's most likely to have made a completely unrealistic New Year's resolution?
Who's most likely to have a hidden talent for guessing movie endings?
Who's most likely to have a completely illegible signature or, conversely, a super elaborate one?
Who's most likely to have had a laughing fit while exercising?
Who's most likely to have a bucket list with some slightly crazy things on it?
Who's most likely to have tried a dumb TikTok challenge (and maybe gotten hurt)?
Who's most likely to be the heaviest sleeper and never hear alarms (or friends trying to wake them)?
Who's most likely to have criticized a movie/show without actually seeing it?
Who's most likely to be terrified of needles or getting blood drawn?
Who's most likely to have a talent for coming up with last-minute excuses?

So, any interesting reveals? That's what these questions are for: spicing up conversations, uncovering funny stories, and seeing your friends (and yourself!) in a new light.

Just remember to stay cool and respectful. It's not about judging or making anyone uncomfortable. Use these moments to strengthen your bonds and, most importantly, have a good laugh!